音乐家和歌手

MainEditor说

AAAAAAND Suno AI and Udio AI came to this world... This was faster than we expected!

Cornelius (低)说

Audiences want to know their favourite musicians as people. For AI to replace them, it would have to replace them in all the functions of celebrity, not merely musical performance.

Minh Đức (低)说

If we work in a profession related to music, we must have imagination to produce a perfect work. That is something robots cannot do.

Mr.Unknown说

AI cannot bring in the authenticity and emotions of a human voice.

Also about the creativity, AI may not be able to think and come up with some new creative ability when it comes to music as it will only produce what it knows, where as a musicians creativity is spontaneous you'd never know what clicks in your mind all of a sudden and becomes something that is loved by the world.

Paul Wainwright (没有机会)说

Musicians and singers are employed in two ways: recording and live performance. Recording is sure to eliminate most jobs, but the live performance will endure.

Tyson N (适度)说

I've seen so much covers using AI, and to be honest they are improving so much in such a short time. Eventually AI will sound no different from human singers

Brewer Shettles (极有可能)说

AI will never rest. Will constantly learn. Will revise rules as it learns. Will set high goals and constantly exceed them.

anonymous (低)说

The problem with generative ai music as it exists at this moment, is that it doesn’t do a good job at translating what’s in the artist’s head into the generated file. Sure, you may get a track that fits the bill, but it’s not gonna be the sound that’s in your head. Maybe it will one day, but you can’t be too sure.

Richard (极有可能)说

AI models such as Google’s MusicLM will make the process of manually writing and recording music totally obsolete in the very near future. Considering the music industry is currently in a state of collapse, these changes will be welcomed by most of society.

laila (低)说

became humans have more creativity

Otis (低)说

AI isn't really AI, but an advanced automation learning algorithm. It can replicate, but it can't actually create. To do that, it would require actual self awareness.

bocchi说

Music, at least with more artistic intent than commercial success, is embedded with humanity. Human singing is different from AI -- I am a vocaloid fan, but vocaloids are fictional characters. We can't truly connect with or idolise them as much as human musicians.
This reality is literally Carole and Tuesday.

Brandon Finley说

I thought online live shows would be able to take over real shows during COVID, but post-COVID it's pretty apparent that fans wanna see their favorite artists live and rock out.

diarmuid (低)说

the element of emotion and personality associated with musicianship is a very human trait and i do not believe that this can be replicated by artificial intelligence at least for now

Sloan. (低)说

Although there is robots that can play instruments I think nothing will ever recreate human feelings and human error and flaws. The beauty of music is that we suck at it and can be vulnerable. You make your trip ups part of the dance.

K (不确定)说

Music making is getting easier, hence more of the less talented ones can make good music. With the help of the AI, creating a good song, will be very easy. And relatively good music producers will flood the industry.

And pricewise: Even free and open source software, like Ardour and MIXXX are good nowadays. It is getting cheaper setting up a studio.

More people in the music industry = Less money

Sammy (没有机会)说

Nothing compares to songs you know have come from a real places, and absolutely nothing compares to seeing those songs played live by real people standing mere meters away…

Gabriel (低)说

I am a composer and know exactly what the AI is capable of doing. For some styles of music, where nobody cares who made the music, yes, it will suffice. Random sound and underscore behind video games, for example.

But we, as humans, love a good backstory, overcoming obstacles and connecting at an emotional level. So, I think the immediate future is cyborg. We will use AI but will add ourselves to it.

I listen to a lot of this software's output, and the music feels random.

AJ (不确定)说

Music creation will mostly be replaced by AI, but live performances will be hard to replace.

Peter (没有机会)说

Originality and interpretation requires combination emotion and knowledge