Musiker und Sänger

Already have AI generated songs but people still mostly prefer actual people.

Recorded music could very easily be automated, and unfortunately we're already seeing this happen with big record labels going all in on the new AI technology. The live show however will never be replaced by AI, and real music enthusiasts will always seek out "real"music instead of the formulated hits big labels pump out.

how would robots make music without copying other people?

Music comes from what we feel and our life. Robots can't have feelings and tend to have creepy voices. Music is to emotional to be replaced by robots or AI

Humans will want to listen to music made by other humans.

There's a reason people pay to see other people perform at concerts

I don't wanna see a live concert played by robots and if you know that a real person made a song and not AI, it's kinda better

It's a human to human thing. It's always been this way

Robots aren’t creative duh

the music they make is very similar even now, especially the vocals. even the working logic of artificial intelligence does not allow for originality, so it is impossible.

I saw a few advertisements for an app that makes music with AI, and it could be better. I also tried making lyrics with ChatGPT once (don't ask why); they can't do it that well. AI can only do some things well regarding music (at least from a few experiences of mine).

Music and art as a whole is an expression of human emotions. Although AI can replicate music, it cant replicate the passion put into it

Robots will not have the same human emotion to their songs than humans.

you need a stable singing voice or a good songwriting skills and I don't think normal robots can do that

Well, musicians are in trouble for a long time.

We are already using DAW and VSTIs for recording. So if it is not a complex classical music piece there is no need for musicians. I'm not even mentioning workstation and digital synthesizer era.

There are already acoustic pianos that can play itself! We may see self playing instruments more in the future. If they sync them together; maybe one day we don't need live musicians.

Suno AI is not good enough to replace DAW and DAW user. So many things are missing. No effects, you can't use your own melody and so on. AI supported DAW may help so much for music creation. It may also reduce the cost and we may finally hear good quality music again, who knows?

When it comes to singers though; I think it is impossible to replace. Because if all you care is the song itself, then play it through speakers. You don't need to go to concert. Imitating is not the only problem. You can't emotionally connect to AI that much. When you become a fan of a singer, you start following him/her on social media, you may even talk with them if you have luck. You may also follow their overall life and thoughts. What about AI? It is just a software, no human being.

Audiences want to know their favourite musicians as people. For AI to replace them, it would have to replace them in all the functions of celebrity, not merely musical performance.

how would a robot make an orginal song

it is nearly impossible to automate a musicians style

AAAAAAND Suno AI and Udio AI came to this world... This was faster than we expected!

If we work in a profession related to music, we must have imagination to produce a perfect work. That is something robots cannot do.