מנהלי מוסיקה ומלחינים

beanz (אין סיכוי) 1 month ago

Because Automated machines don't have emotions (as you probably know by asking Siri or whatever,) a conductor, for one, would be impossible to replace because it would lack, first of all, free movement of the joints, and in the event it does become automated, would look EXTREMELY uncanny...

0 0 Reply

Nicholas Venet (אין סיכוי) 4 months ago

music can be performed by bots and you can have a robot conductor however the emotion of a musician, providing interpertions of word is not able to be replicated by robots

0 0 Reply

Joey (נמוך) 4 months ago

You need a lot of emotion - something unable to be reproduced by robots - to have and do this job well. Also, originality is a BIG part of the job.

0 0 Reply

Bel (נמוך) 11 months ago

Robots (IA's) will never match human creativity.

2 0 Reply

Joe (נמוך) 1 year ago

It makes sense why some people would use AI for small things, like as background music for a YouTube video. Everywhere else, you'd have to have human minds and human limbs behind it. The way I see it, AI will never be Hans Zimmer or Jacob Collier. Not by a longshot.

2 0 Reply

Jaybird (נמוך) 1 year ago

It’s too complex and subjective for individual AI feedback to be effective over the arc of learning

1 0 Reply

J (נמוך) 1 year ago

The only people are impressed by the music AIVA and other AI technologies create are people who either lack an ability to evaluate music properly (they are not musical themselves and don't actively listen to music) or people who stand to gain if they can replace the creativity of composers with a program.

This is without taking into account all of the interpersonal elements of composition, which are also not well understood by people who don't do this work.

Finally, given that humans are subject to copyright law and that the level of imitation and inspiration from previous works is controlled and limited by these laws, it is unlikely that music created by AI that was not drastically reshaped by a human composer would avoid copyright lawsuits or be subject to copyright itself, as current technology in this field only knows how to aggregate and make stylistic choices based on probability. A human composer is not going to waste time fiddling with AI compositions to "get them there" when they could just write something themselves.

Show me an evangelist who actually produces music and isn't heavily invested in AI themselves in some way, and I'll reconsider.

4 0 Reply

Rachel Farina (סביר להניח מאוד) 2 years ago

AI is already composing and generating music. Algorithms can already curate. There will always be work for the top - John Williams, Hans Zimmer won't find their work gone. But for indie films and anyone on a budget, AI composing will be the thing within the next few years. The technology grows at an exponential pace. Though stuff sounds embarrassing now, six months from now, that will not be the case.

0 4 Reply

Marcus (סביר להניח מאוד) 2 years ago

As we already see everything can be done by sophisticated software. It started with pictures, then text and next is music. We all thought Software can never replace artists, but as we see that was a wrong assupmtion and in fact got hit first by the "AI" hype. With enough data and "training" any sort of music will be possible. Using a DAW will be obsolete.

0 2 Reply

Fl studio 20 (סביר להניח מאוד) 2 years ago

Art like graphic design is already being synthesized with superb detail using AI. What's to say that music isn't next?

0 3 Reply

yo lads (מתונה) 3 years ago

i seen some robots making chunes and people saying they bussin beats
bye bye dutse, hesh and koot

1 2 Reply

Zac (אין סיכוי) 4 years ago

Even if they could it wouldn't be the same as a person composing and putting their input and ideas into the composition. The feeling and emotion has to come from within to create something astonishing in my opinion. Because of this, they wouldn't fully replace humans in music writing/composing.

2 0 Reply

John (סביר להניח מאוד) 4 years ago

There are already many ai composers like AIVA, so I am pretty sure in the next 15-20 years ai composers will replace human music composers.

0 1 Reply

DJ (אין סיכוי) 4 years ago

Produce own style of music, create melody you like, there is just no way AI could replace it

1 0 Reply

Gadgetsz 4 years ago

The act of composing will not be replaced BUT it will definitely change and maybe become more easy and accessible for all people. Maybe one day, everyone is a composer because you don't even need to learn score writing, DAW, playing or singing. Maybe just by thinking, you can create masterworks.. We will see?

0 0 Reply

EdwinBrophy 5 years ago

Composing pop music is already nearly completely automated but serious music will continue to require human composers.

1 1 Reply

Joshua 5 years ago

People who learn the same music theories write different songs, so do robots. Robots are rarely likely to replace human beings in the field of composition.

1 1 Reply

Natalie (נמוך) 5 years ago

Music would be awful of it was automated. Music requires feelings to be any good.

1 0 Reply

Joel (אין סיכוי) 6 years ago

Music, or the act of composing music, has no formula of equation to it. Music is the expression of one's emotions, often called the outburst of the soul. A robot or machine is literally incapable of having emotions or a soul, therefore a robot will never be able to replace a human composer.

1 0 Reply

Anomius Maximus (אין סיכוי) 6 years ago

No way a robot would have ever been able to create a song as great, innovative, inspiring and culture changing as the masterpiece that is known as 'All Star' by Smash Mouth.

1 0 Reply